How Route Diversity in SD-WAN Provides MPLS-Like Determinism Required for Real-Time Traffic

August 5, 2018

As I discussed in my previous post, real-time traffic has two characteristics that are challenging for the Internet. First, as the packets have a limited time value and cannot be re-transmitted, any significant change in the transport and packet delivery has the potential of being audible (or visible in the case of video) to the participants. And, as most real-time conversations last orders of magnitude longer than most other types of internet interactions, the probability of a network incident impacting the packet transmission is dramatically higher. The result is that real-time traffic needs a deterministic transport with minimal latency.

SLA-vs-Cost

The challenge is that in the network world getting Service Level Agreement (SLA) determinism generally has a steep price. Whether a dedicated wire or MPLS, the cost of traditional WAN technology increases in direct relationship to determinism. SD-WAN solves this very problem by utilizing route and component diversity made feasible by the improvements in technology and the affordable costs of Internet bandwidth.

The basic concept of SD-WAN is the concept of route diversification. The two SD-WAN edge points (the point between the Enterprise LAN and the carrier WAN) create multiple route paths between them. For example, in the diagram, each of the red paths represents a different route between the SD-WAN node on the left and right. When the actual traffic arrives at the SD-WAN node, it can decide, based on a factor such as traffic type or current route performance, which route to put the actual data packets into.  All of this can be controlled by the SD-WAN controller that oversees the operation.

SD-WAN

While the diagram shows a simple premises SD-WAN, the addition of Points of Presence (POP) in a core cloud SD-WAN enables management of the paths between the POPs. This can enable enhanced determinism as much of the variation in Internet traffic delivery happens in the core that is bypassed by having a cloud core. We will discuss this specific topic in a future post.

The benefits to real-time traffic are clear. In the traditional network, if the path that is currently being used for the real-team session flow is impacted, whether through failures or peering issues that limit capacity, the user traffic will stay in that route and the quality of the real-time interaction traffic may be compromised. In the SD-WAN, the traffic can be dynamically moved from the impacted route to the best route available at that time. Through this mechanism, an SD-WAN has the potential of using the best possible route at any point in time between two locations on the Internet, all of the while using the lower cost service of the open Internet, assuming there are sufficient paths for route diversity.

The result is that SD-WAN changes the determinism and cost model of the modern WAN. because of route diversity and path management, SD-WAN enables the MPLS equivalent determinism required by real-time traffic at close to the open Internet cost model. At the core, the concept is simple, but there are many layers of complexity and value that must be considered as part of a well-engineered SD-WAN solution. For example, the routes must be monitored for their current transport characteristics, the traffic type of flows must be determined, the different flows and their relative policies must be included, and more. All of these are critical for VoIP and other real-time traffic.

SLA-vs-Cost-with-SD-WAN

In considering an SD-WAN solution, there are a number of factors that should be evaluated if optimizing real-time traffic. Whether the SD-WAN is implemented as a premise or cloud solution is a consideration. If backhaul is required and the use of Points of Presence can also have an impact. Also, how the SD-WAN classifies the traffic — this too can have a major impact on real-time determinism. Other considerations like cloud Software as a Service (SaaS) access and security are important. Over the next few months, we will both discuss how to use SD-WAN, but also some of those key characteristics and capabilities that an SD-WAN solution must have to maximize value to real-time traffic.

PhilPhil

PhilPhil

Phil Edholm is the President and Founder of PKE Consulting. PKE consults to end users and vendors in the communications and networking markets. Prior to founding PKE, Phil was Vice President of Technology Strategy and Innovation for Avaya and before that he was CTO/CSO for the Nortel Enterprise business where he led the development of VoIP solutions and multimedia communications as well as IP transport technology. Phil is recognized as an industry leader and visionary. In 2007, he was recognized by Frost and Sullivan with a Lifetime Achievement Award for Growth, Innovation and Leadership in Telecommunications. He has been recognized by the IEEE as the originator of “Edholm’s Law of Bandwidth” as published in July 2004 IEEE Spectrum magazine and as one of the “Top 100 Voices of IP Communications" by Internet Telephony magazine. Phil was a member of the IEEE 802.3 standards committee, developed the first multi-protocol network interfaces, and was a founder of the Frame Relay Forum. Phil has 13 patents and holds a BSME/EE from Kettering University.